Kim Shin-wook, a South Korean footballer who has played for several clubs in the Chinese Super League (CSL), has received mixed reviews during his time at Shanghai Shenhua.

During the 2018 season, Kim made a strong impression on fans and critics alike with his performances. He was one of the standout players for Shanghai Shenhua that year, scoring four goals and providing three assists in just 15 appearances. His efforts helped the club secure a spot in the CSL playoffs, where they eventually lost to eventual champions Beijing Guoan.

However, Kim's performance in the 2019 season was less impressive. He only managed two goals and one assist in 17 games, which led many to question whether he was still capable of performing at the same level as before. Some fans even called for him to be dropped from the team, while others remained optimistic about his future.

Despite these challenges, Kim remains a valuable asset to Shanghai Shenhua. He is known for his technical skills and ability to create chances for his teammates, making him a key player for the team. Despite his struggles in the 2019 season, he showed promise in the 2020 season, scoring six goals and assisting three times in 16 games.

Overall, Kim Shin-wook's rating at Shanghai Shenhua varies depending on the season. While some fans have praised his performances, others have criticized his inconsistent form. However, it seems that Kim is still a valuable addition to the team and will continue to play a crucial role in their success in the future.